Integral bridges with longer spans experience an increased cyclic interaction with their granular backfills, particularly due to seasonal thermal fluctuations. To accurately model this interaction behaviour under cyclic loading, it is crucial to employ appropriate constitutive models and meticulously calibrate and test them. For this purpose, in this paper two advanced elastoplastic (DeltaSand, Sanisand-MS) and two hypoplastic (Hypo+IGS, Hypo+ISA) constitutive models with focus on small strain and cyclic behaviour are investigated. The soil models are calibrated based on a comprehensive laboratory programme of a representative highly compacted gravel backfill material for bridges. The calibration procedure is shown in detail and the model capabilities and limitations are discussed on the element test level. Additional triaxial tests with repeated un- and reloading reveal significant over- and undershooting effects for the majority of the investigated material models. Finally, cyclic finite element analyses on the soil-structure interaction of an integral bridge are conducted to compare the performance of the soil models. Qualitatively similar cyclic evolution of earth pressures are detected for the soil models at various bridge lengths and test settings. However, a substantially different cyclic settlement behaviour is observed. Additionally, the investigation highlights severe overshooting effects associated with the tested hypoplastic soil models. This phenomenon is studied in detail using a single integration point analysis. Supplementary studies reveal that the foot point deformation of the abutment significantly influences the lateral passive stress mobilisation and the amount of its increase with growing seasonal cycles.
Steel piles driven into the seabed for offshore structures regularly experience monotonic and cyclic axial loading. The bearing capacity of these piles under cyclic loading degrades with the number of cycles due to the reduction in skin friction. Limited experimental data has led to the development of interaction diagrams, which predict the number of loading cycles until failure based on the mean load and the amplitude of the cyclic load, both often normalized through the static pile bearing capacity. However, these diagrams do not account for varying soil conditions or pile geometries. In this paper, the authors extend the previously developed Capacity Degradation Method (CDM) by incorporating the hypoplastic material law, which accounts for loading and unloading paths, stress levels, and the change of soil void ratios. New interaction diagrams have been developed for different pile geometries. Additionally, the pullout capacities of piles with varying diameters and embedded lengths under different loading cycles are investigated.
Numerous geotechnical applications are significantly influenced by changes of moisture conditions, such as energy geostructures, nuclear waste disposal storage, embankments, landslides, and pavements. Additionally, the escalating impacts of climate change have started to amplify the influence of severe seasonal variations on the performance of foundations. These scenarios induce thermo-hydro-mechanical loads in the soil that can also vary in a cyclic manner. Robust constitutive numerical models are essential to analyze such behaviors. This article proposes an extended hypoplastic constitutive model capable of predicting the behavior of partially saturated fine-grained soils under monotonic and cyclic loading. The proposed model was developed through a hierarchical procedure that integrates existing features for accounting large strain behavior, asymptotic states, and small strain stiffness effects, and considers the dependency of strain accumulation rate on the number of cycles. To achieve this, the earlier formulation by Wong and Ma & scaron;& iacute;n (CG 61:355-369, 2014) was enhanced with the Improvement of the intergranular strain (ISI) concept proposed by Duque et al. (AG 15:3593-3604, 2020), extended with a new modification to predict the increase in soil stiffness with suction under cyclic loading. Furthermore, the water retention curve was modified with a new formulation proposed by Svoboda et al. (AG 18:3193-3211, 2023), which reproduces the nonlinear dependency of the degree of saturation on suction. The model's capabilities were examined using experimental results on a completely decomposed tuff subjected to monotonic and cyclic loading under different saturation ranges. The comparison between experimental measurements and numerical predictions suggests that the model reasonably captures the monotonic and cyclic behavior of fine-grained soil under partially saturated conditions. Some limitations of the extended model are as well remarked.
Due to the increasing need to find new alternative energy sources, more attention has been given to the development of energy geostructures, which not only serve as foundations, but also employ the geothermal properties of soils for heating and cooling structures, inducing mechanical and thermal loads. Additionally, the up -growing effects of climate change are influencing the performance of foundations due to the increase in temperature and seasonal variations. The previously mentioned examples correspond to scenarios where soils are subjected to thermo-hydro-mechanical loading, which can vary cyclically. To predict this behavior, in this article a coupled thermo-hydro-mechanical hypoplastic model for partially saturated fine-grained soils that accounts for both monotonic and cyclic loading is presented. The proposed constitutive model is capable of reproducing temperature and suction effects at large strains and asymptotic states. Additionally, coupled effects are predicted by incorporating a Water Retention Curve (WRC) that depends on temperature and void ratio. Small strain stiffness effects are captured based on the Improvement of the Intergranular Strain concept (ISI), modified to include the influence of temperature under cyclic loading, as well as a temperature dependent secant shear modulus formulation at very small strains. The capabilities of the constitutive model were evaluated through element tests simulations of monotonic and cyclic mechanical loading tests under temperature- and suction- controlled conditions, as well as heating/cooling experiments at constant stress. The proposed constitutive model shows accurate predictions when compare to experimental data. Nevertheless, some limitations have been encountered and further discussed.
While hypoplastic models have demonstrated accurate predictions of sand behavior under monotonic loading, their accuracy diminishes when applied to cyclic loading conditions. To address this limitation, the intergranular strain approach is used as an extension to the model. The current investigation focuses on the analysis of two variants: the original Intergranular Strain (IS) approach proposed by Niemunis and Herle (1997) and the Intergranular Strain Anisotropy (ISA) by Fuentes et al. (2019). Although both models have the same objective, they present distinct mathematical structures and therefore different repercussions on the simulations. In this study, sand Hypoplasticity is enhanced with IS and ISA, and employed to simulate a series of experimental tests conducted on Fontainebleau sand. These tests encompass isotropic compression, drained monotonic triaxial, and undrained cyclic triaxial tests, while considering different initial densities and test characteristics. Furthermore, the calibrated models were applied to simulate a series of centrifuge tests, involving a pile embedded in the same sand, which is subjected to various episodes of monotonic and cyclic lateral loading. A comparison and discussion of the similarities and differences in elemental and finite element predictions, arising from the two intergranular strain formulations is presented.
Constitutive models that are able to accurately predict cyclic soil behaviour are crucial for finite element design of offshore foundation or railway embankments. Basic hypoplastic models introduce the history of loading in state variables such as the stress and void ratio and are therefore incapable of describing small-strain stiffness and cyclic loading. In this work, clay hypoplasticity is extended with a modified intergranular strain proposed by Duque et al. [3]. The new model is compared to the one coupled previously with ISA based on unconventional as well as complex cyclic loading paths. Abilities and limitations of the models are addressed: (i) showing that both models predict a reduction in strain accumulation with an increasing number of cycles. (ii) For both models pronounced over- and undershooting effects can occur for certain cyclic loading paths and certain parameters. Despite the consensus in the literature, the results show that a yield surface in the (intergranular) strain space is not sufficient to ban these effects. Furthermore, the models' predictive capabilities are verified with simulations of monotonic and cyclic tests of Lower Rhine clay.
Numerical modeling serves as a widely utilized method for addressing geotechnical concerns. A pivotal aspect of this modeling process is the accurate characterization of material behavior. The connection between stress and strain tensors within soil is explicated by the soil constitutive equation, which is reliant on factors like soil type and deformation circumstances. One notable model is hypoplasticity, which has been in use for more than three decades. This research aims to calibrate the hypoplastic parameters for Danube sand using the SoilTest Module of PLAXIS. The constitutive hypoplastic model for Danube sand was fine-tuned through a series of numerical simulations. The parameter calibration occurred twice: initially according to 5 cycles of hysteresis loop of stress-strain diagram of cyclic triaxial testing, and then subsequently in accordance with strain trends observed after ten thousand cycles. A comparison was drawn between parameters determined from the overall strain trends and those calibrated based on the five cycles. The findings indicate that while the model calibrated during a specific segment of testing can accurately predict strain values during compression and extension, it falls short in forecasting the accumulated settlement following prolonged cyclic loading. This suggests the model's limited capability in anticipating long-term cyclic load effects on settlement behavior.
Laboratory test programs on gravel are rare due to the maximum grain size of the material. In this paper an experimental program with triaxial tests under cyclic loading and oedometric tests on highly compacted gravel specimens, representative for bridge backfills materials, is summarized. It is used to calibrate a hypoplastic constitutive model, which includes an extension for intergranular strain to account for the cyclic loading behaviour. So far calibrated parameter sets of this soil model are scarce in literature, especially for coarse grained materials. The calibrated parameter set can be used in numerical studies, e. g. on the cyclic soil structure interaction of integral railway bridges.